Barb’s challenge was simple, at least according to her; she needed help training and managing her rapidly-growing customer service department. This is a case of mis-directed energy, done so by a manager confusing activity with growth.
In this situation, think for a moment about what’s wrong with this challenge. “I need training and management help as our customer service department continues to add seats.”
First, this is not only one challenge, it is TWO: training and management. You can’t solve two things at once.
Second, training is a solution and not a problem.
Third, there’s something wrong with adding seats to a customer service center given that service centers field calls from customers needing help.
Yes, you’ve got it. Customer service centers do not grow when everything is working properly.
Here was my dialog.
Barb: “What do you recomend we do?”
David: “Before we move forward, you need to acknowlege you’ve got bigger issues.”
Barb: “What do you mean?”
David: “Let me give you a list of concerns…
1. You’re missing ship dates
2. Your sales people are not showing when needed.
3. Orders are being shipped incorrectly.
4. There are issues with your invoices and statements.
5. Customers are unsure of how to place reorders.
6. New prospects are confused.
7. The product is not always up to standards.
8. Marketing materials and support are lacking punch.
9. Employees are not getting back to customers.
10 ….
Barb: “How did you figure that out with just one question?”
David: “It’s easy. Customer service centers would shrink if everything was done perfectly. If marketing materials were complete, sales people did their jobs to perfection, orders were packaged and shipped on time, and accounting done accurately, no one would call you.”
This food service HR Manager confessed that many of the situations described were part of the company’s challenges. For example,, one issuesis the lack of support to new territories. When entering a new territory, the company can’t afford to run complete advertising campaigns due to the lack of penetration into the market. Therefore, the new customer, who’s selling the company’s turkey line, inevitably does not make the ROI expected, resulting in issues from the start.
Now imagine if Barb had continued down this path. She would have hired a trainer to help train new customer service people and possibly more management. When done, she’d have a larger payroll and more customers to fend off, creating a vicious cycle.
If she retargeted her energies into automated custoemer service counters, fixing the shipping, refocusing psychographic overlays for market penetration, improving the sales process, insuring accurate shipping, etc., her company would be much better off.
One of the hardest choices management has to make is what challenge to address first given that there are so many to choose from. In the world of decision making, making sure you address the right problem is the key to moving forward or backwards.